Interventions for Treatment of Alcohol Use Disorder

The NativeAIR treatment section includes interventions designed to treat alcohol use disorder (AUD) and support recovery among American Indian/Alaska Native (AI/AN) communities. Alcohol treatment and recovery services are often limited on reservations, and even Indian Health Services clinics may have limited resources to offer specialty services. Some epidemiological studies have found high rates of AUD among AI/AN populations, while others have found high rates of abstinence or drinking in moderation with large variations by age, gender, Tribe, cultural group, and residential pattern.

Historically, alcohol treatment services and research were conducted mostly in residential settings located far from the communities with relatively few outpatient and recovery services. Alcohol treatment research in AI/AN communities is in the early stages in terms of the number of studies and the scientific rigor of the interventions tested. Nearly all the studies included in NativeAIR focus on the treatment of adults. Many of the older treatment studies utilized pre-post designs with newer studies utilizing more rigorous multisite, controlled trials.

Of the interventions reviewed, many do not report longer term follow-up data, making it difficult to determine long-term effectiveness. Some studies did not separate alcohol outcomes from broader substance use outcomes. In addition to the need for more treatment interventions, there is a growing interest in developing culturally appropriate recovery interventions.

The following interventions were selected from published peer-reviewed studies and reviewed according to a rigorous set of criteria. Native and non-Native researchers conducting alcohol research in Native populations led this review. About NativeAIR presents information about the intervention selection criteria and coding scheme, which includes elements of cultural or Tribal inclusion.

Interventions can be filtered and sorted by different variables to find the interventions that may be most appropriate for your needs. The Description of Intervention Variables page describes all intervention variables.

 

Drum-Assisted Recovery Therapy for Native Americans (DARTNA)The DARTNA intervention is a drumming behavior therapy that incorporates drumming and talking circles, and uses the 12 Steps of AA and Narcotics Anonymous (NA) programs within the conceptual framework of the Northern Plains Medicine Wheel.
Outcomes

Low Level of Change

Costs
Start-Up Cost: $$$Medium
Ongoing Cost: $$$Medium
Cultural Engagement
Cultural Inclusion: High
Tribal Inclusion: Medium
SettingClinical/Healthcare, Urban
ParticipantsYoung Adult, Adult, Senior; Native; Female, Male
DeliverySmall Group, Medium Group, Face-to-Face
Staffing NeedsCommunity Leader
Research DesignRandomized controlled experimental design
Developmental stage of researchEarly Stage
I Mua Mau OhanaA long-term, residential treatment program for Hawai’ian adolescents that includes culturally-based experiential learning, individual and family therapy, education, and spirituality.
Outcomes

Medium/Mixed Level of Change

Costs
Start-Up Cost: $$$High
Ongoing Cost: $$$High
Cultural Engagement
Cultural Inclusion: High
Tribal Inclusion: None Reported
SettingClinical/Healthcare
ParticipantsAdolescent, Young Adult; Native, Non-Native; Female, Male
DeliveryIndividual, Small Group, Medium Group, Multi-level, Face-to-Face
Staffing NeedsCertified Professional
Research DesignPre-/post-intervention data
Developmental stage of researchEarly Stage
Culturally Tailored Motivational Interviewing and Community Reinforcement Approach (MICRA)Motivational interviewing (MI) and Community Reinforcement Approach (CRA) were culturally adapted for American Indians to create MICRA, a substance use treatment intervention.
Outcomes

Low Level of Change

Costs
Start-Up Cost: $$$Medium
Ongoing Cost: $$$Medium
Cultural Engagement
Cultural Inclusion: High
Tribal Inclusion: Medium
SettingClinical/Healthcare, Reservation, Rural
ParticipantsYoung Adult, Adult; Native; Female, Male
DeliveryIndividual, Face-to-Face
Staffing NeedsCertified Professional, Community Member
Research DesignRandomized controlled experimental design
Developmental stage of researchMid Stage
Sacred Journey—Cognitive Processing TherapySacred Journey is a cultural adaptation of cognitive processing therapy (CPT) a cognitive behavioral trauma-focused treatment that uses cognitive restructuring to resolve post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms.
Outcomes

Medium/Mixed Level of Change

Costs
Start-Up Cost: $$$Medium
Ongoing Cost: $$$Medium
Cultural Engagement
Cultural Inclusion: High
Tribal Inclusion: High
SettingClinical/Healthcare, Reservation, Rural
ParticipantsYoung Adult, Adult, Senior; Native; Female
DeliveryIndividual, Face-to-Face
Staffing NeedsNot Specified
Research DesignRandomized controlled experimental design
Developmental stage of researchMid Stage
Sweat Lodge Ceremony (SLC)Tribally affiliated jail-based treatment staff utilized sweat lodge ceremonies to address alcohol use among incarcerated Native American individuals.
Outcomes

No Change

Costs
Start-Up Cost: $$$Medium
Ongoing Cost: $$$Low
Cultural Engagement
Cultural Inclusion: High
Tribal Inclusion: High
SettingReservation, Rural, Social Services
ParticipantsYoung Adult, Adult, Senior; Native; Male
DeliveryFace-to-Face
Staffing NeedsNot Specified
Research DesignPre-/post-intervention data
Developmental stage of researchEarly Stage
Transitional Recovery and Culture Program (TRCP)American Indian peer mentors in recovery delivered a culturally adapted peer recovery support intervention to American Indians recovering from alcohol misuse.
Outcomes

Medium/Mixed Level of Change

Costs
Start-Up Cost: $$$Medium
Ongoing Cost: $$$Medium
Cultural Engagement
Cultural Inclusion: High
Tribal Inclusion: Medium
SettingReservation, Rural, Urban
ParticipantsYoung Adult, Adult; Native; Female, Male
DeliveryIndividual, Face-to-Face, Telephone Call
Staffing NeedsCommunity Leader, Community Member
Research DesignPre-/post-intervention data
Developmental stage of researchEarly Stage
“Nemi’simk, Seeing Oneself” Intervention ProgramAn early intervention for alcohol misuse among First Nations youth that integrated traditional cultural knowledge and teachings with established cognitive behavioral strategies.
Outcomes

Low Level of Change

Costs
Start-Up Cost: $$$High
Ongoing Cost: $$$Medium
Cultural Engagement
Cultural Inclusion: High
Tribal Inclusion: Medium
SettingRural, School
ParticipantsAdolescent, Young Adult; Native; Female, Male
DeliverySmall Group, Face-to-Face
Staffing NeedsAdvanced Degree (post BA) Professional, Certified Professional, Community Leader
Research DesignQuasi experimental design
Developmental stage of researchEarly Stage
Driving While Intoxicated (DWI) Prevention ProgramThis 28-day treatment program aimed to prevent incarcerated first-time offenders from repeated instances of driving under the influence of alcohol by providing individual counseling, group treatment, and post-discharge monitoring.
Outcomes

High Level of Change

Costs
Start-Up Cost: $$$Medium
Ongoing Cost: $$$Medium
Cultural Engagement
Cultural Inclusion: High
Tribal Inclusion: None Reported
SettingOther
ParticipantsYoung Adult, Adult, Senior; Native, Non-Native; Female, Male
DeliveryIndividual, Small Group, Face-to-Face
Staffing NeedsNot Specified
Research DesignRandomized controlled experimental design
Developmental stage of researchMature Stage
The Shadow ProjectThe Shadow Project contrasted a culturally enriched adolescent inpatient treatment as usual to an intervention that added a culturally adapted family-based treatment.
Outcomes

No Change

Costs
Start-Up Cost: $$$High
Ongoing Cost: $$$High
Cultural Engagement
Cultural Inclusion: Medium
Tribal Inclusion: None Reported
SettingHome, Clinical/Healthcare, Reservation
ParticipantsYoung Adult, Adult; Native; Female, Male
DeliveryIndividual, Small Group, Multi-level, Face-to-Face
Staffing NeedsNot Specified
Research DesignQuasi experimental design
Developmental stage of researchEarly Stage
Contingency ManagementContingency management is an intervention in which incentives are provided when abstinence from alcohol or drugs is biologically confirmed.
Outcomes

Medium/Mixed Level of Change

Costs
Start-Up Cost: $$$Medium
Ongoing Cost: $$$Medium
Cultural Engagement
Cultural Inclusion: Low
Tribal Inclusion: Medium
SettingCommunity Center, Clinical/Healthcare, Reservation, Rural, Urban
ParticipantsYoung Adult, Adult, Senior; Native; Female, Male
DeliveryIndividual, Face-to-Face
Staffing NeedsAdvanced Degree (post BA) Professional, Community Member
Research DesignRandomized controlled experimental design
Developmental stage of researchMid Stage
Disulfiram Community Treatment ProgramAn intervention for Navajo adults offering supervised Disulfiram administration, counseling (as needed), and case management.
Outcomes

Low Level of Change

Costs
Start-Up Cost: $$$High
Ongoing Cost: $$$High
Cultural Engagement
Cultural Inclusion: Low
Tribal Inclusion: Low
SettingClinical/Healthcare, Reservation, Rural
ParticipantsYoung Adult, Adult; Native; Female, Male
DeliveryIndividual, Face-to-Face
Staffing NeedsNot Specified
Research DesignPre-/post-intervention data
Developmental stage of researchEarly Stage
Motivational Enhancement Therapy (MET), Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), and Twelve-Step Facilitation treatments (TSF)The effectiveness of three evidenced-based treatments (MET, CBT, and TSF) were compared among Native American patients with alcohol use disorder (AUD).
Outcomes

Medium/Mixed Level of Change

Costs
Start-Up Cost: $$$High
Ongoing Cost: $$$High
Cultural Engagement
Cultural Inclusion: None Reported
Tribal Inclusion: None Reported
SettingClinical/Healthcare, Urban
ParticipantsAdult; Native; Female, Male
DeliveryIndividual, Face-to-Face
Staffing NeedsNot Specified
Research DesignRandomized controlled experimental design
Developmental stage of researchEarly Stage
Naltrexone TreatmentNaltrexone, a medication that decreases cravings and urges to use alcohol, was found useful in reducing relapse to drinking among rural Alaskan alcohol dependent patients.
Outcomes

Medium/Mixed Level of Change

Costs
Start-Up Cost: $$$High
Ongoing Cost: $$$High
Cultural Engagement
Cultural Inclusion: None Reported
Tribal Inclusion: Low
SettingClinical/Healthcare, Rural
ParticipantsYoung Adult, Adult, Senior; Native, Non-Native; Female, Male
DeliveryIndividual, Face-to-Face
Staffing NeedsAdvanced Degree (post BA) Professional, Certified Professional
Research DesignRandomized controlled experimental design
Developmental stage of researchEarly Stage
Telephone Aftercare ProjectAmerican Indian adults who completed culturally specific residential treatment for alcohol use were provided telephone aftercare contacts upon return to their reservation.
Outcomes

Medium/Mixed Level of Change

Costs
Start-Up Cost: $$$Low
Ongoing Cost: $$$Low
Cultural Engagement
Cultural Inclusion: None Reported
Tribal Inclusion: None Reported
SettingHome, Reservation
ParticipantsYoung Adult, Adult; Native; Female, Male
DeliveryIndividual, Telephone Call
Staffing NeedsNot Specified
Research DesignPre-/post-intervention data
Developmental stage of researchEarly Stage